Living With Non-Dischargeable Student Loans
The federal bankruptcy code states that a debtor may obtain a discharge of a government-sponsored student loan only if repaying the loan would impose an “undue hardship” on the debtor and his dependents. Most bankruptcy courts interpret “undue hardship” as meaning that the debtor cannot repay the loan and maintain a minimal standard of living. As a result of this very high bar, it is rare that a student loan is discharged during bankruptcy.
Consequently, many bankruptcy debtors are caught in a student loan trap of being unable to pay on the student loan and the interest continues to accrue. While discharging the student loan may not be possible, there are options for dealing with a student loan during and after bankruptcy.
First, the student loan lender or collection agency is strictly forbidden from engaging in any collection action during the bankruptcy. This protection (known as the “automatic stay”) may last from a few months during a Chapter 7 to several years during a Chapter 13 repayment plan. Interest may continue to accrue and will be tacked-on at the end of the bankruptcy case.
Second, if the student loan was not defaulted prior to the bankruptcy filing (meaning no payment for more than 270 days), the account will usually be re-aged and is considered current upon the conclusion of the bankruptcy case. This is a good time to negotiate with the lender for a payment plan you can afford. If the student loan was defaulted prior to the bankruptcy, the lender may offer a loan rehabilitation program.
Finally, your student loan lender has many repayment options after your bankruptcy case ends, including the Income Based Repayment Plan which limits your loan repayment to 15% of your income and offers loan forgiveness after 25 years of repayment (or 10 years for public service employees).
If you are struggling with student loan debt, speak to an experienced bankruptcy attorney and discuss your options. Your attorney can explain the many ways for dealing with student loan debt and can help you decide on a course of action that is best for you and your family.
Bankruptcy and Court Ordered Marital Obligations
Bankruptcy can have a serious impact on an ex-spouse. That is because a family court will often assign payment of a joint debt to one party only. In many cases the obligated party lacks the resources to pay the debt in full or to refinance it. Therefore the ex-spouse remains legally obligated to the creditor. This is often the case with automobile debt and credit cards with large balances.
A court-ordered debt to a former spouse is given special consideration by the bankruptcy laws. In a Chapter 7 bankruptcy case these debts are generally non-dischargeable. An order directing payment to a third party (e.g. a mortgage payment) is also generally non-dischargeable if the payment is effectively a form of spousal support. Even an obligation to pay your ex-spouse’s attorney fees in connection with the divorce proceeding is generally non-dischargeable.
While past due support obligations are also non-dischargeable debts in a Chapter 13 bankruptcy, debts not in the nature of support (e.g. a division of marital property) can be discharged. The ex-spouse must contest the debtor’s characterization of the obligation and convince the bankruptcy court that the debt is a support obligation in order to save it from discharge. If the court determines the debt is a support obligation, it must be paid by the debtor through the Chapter 13 bankruptcy.
Whether the family court-ordered obligation arises from a property division or from a support obligation, the ex-spouse will likely suffer harm from the debtor’s bankruptcy filing. The sad truth is that any non-payment of a joint monthly obligation will harm the ex-spouse’s credit report and there is little that can be done to remedy it. If the debt is discharged through the debtor’s Chapter 13 bankruptcy, the creditor may elect to pursue the ex-spouse and there will be no recourse against the debtor.
Regardless whether you or your ex-spouse owes a court-ordered joint obligation, if bankruptcy is in the future, you should seek professional help. It is important to evaluate the impact the bankruptcy will have on the debt and determine a course of action that will best protect you. Timing can be very critical, so consult with an experienced bankruptcy attorney early.
Discharging Credit Card Balances
As a general rule, credit card debt is among the easiest type of debt to discharge during a Chapter 7 or Chapter 13 Bankruptcy. However, in some cases credit card companies will dispute the discharge of credit card debt by filing an adversarial proceeding against the debtor in the bankruptcy court. The creditor may claim that all or a portion of the debt is non-dischargeable. Debts that are declared non-dischargeable may have to be paid during the bankruptcy, or may survive the bankruptcy altogether.
A credit card company may claim that the debtor committed fraud in obtaining or using the credit card. If the creditor can prove that the card was obtained under false pretenses (i.e. that the application was false), the credit card debt may be declared non-dischargeable because of the fraud.
A credit card company may also claim that charges were placed on the credit card when the debtor had no intention to repay the debt. Additionally, a presumption of fraud arises where luxury goods and services are purchased or cash advances are taken shortly before the filing of a bankruptcy case.
Credit card companies are entitled to notice of a debtor’s bankruptcy case, and these companies monitor bankruptcy cases for signs of fraud. Certain actions send up a red flag including:
- Filing bankruptcy on a new card;
- Taking a cash advance prior to filing;
- Charges for travel or vacation;
- A debt transfer from one card to another;
- Credit charges while unemployed; and
- Charges made after consulting a bankruptcy attorney.
The more time between the credit card activity and the bankruptcy filing, the less likely the charge will cause a discharge dispute. The best advice is: if you are considering bankruptcy, stop using your credit cards. Consult with your bankruptcy attorney regarding the best way to discharge your credit card debt.